Your Destination for Quality Finds

Chambersburg's Premier Consignment Shop

Gift Certificates, Loyalty Cards, Layaways, and Wish Lists.

Give the gift of choice with our customizable certificates, perfect for any occasion. Join our program for exclusive benefits, rewards, and discounts. Layaway & Reserve items, pay in installments, and track your desired treasures hassle-free.

The Essence of Chambersburg's Consignment Culture

Welcome to our Chambersburg consignment shop, a haven for those seeking one-of-a-kind treasures. Nestled in the heart of Pennsylvania, our shop is a testament to the art of discovery. Step inside, and you'll be greeted by an eclectic array of furniture, clothing, and decor pieces waiting to be explored. Each item tells a story, waiting for its next chapter with you. Embrace the thrill of the hunt and uncover hidden gems that resonate with your style and personality.

Journey Through Time

From Boutique to Emporium

Established in 1996. We started as a small consignment boutique, and 25 years later, we have become a large, upscale consignment shop with just about everything. We carry furniture, quality clothing and formals for the entire family, jewelry, Harley Davidson attire, handicap equipment, vintage clothing, and costumes, and much more. We have over 6,000 active local and long-distance consignors and are growing.

Browse Our Shop

Unveil Unique Treasures

Discover Our Specialties

When you enter our shop, you never know what treasures you're going to find. Our inventory is always changing to make space for more and more beautiful furniture, clothing, and decor. We're far from your average consignment shop, too.


With over 6,000 active consignors and a selection of new and rarely used items, Why Buy New offers an upscale boutique experience at an affordable price. Whether you're looking for something specific or just browsing for something to catch your eye, you'll find exactly what you need here.

Contact Us
home decor

Sell With Us

Button
Records

ElevatE THE Shopping Experience

Enjoy Vintage Boutique Vibes and Finds at Affordable Prices

Prepare to indulge in an upscale boutique experience without breaking the bank at our Chambersburg consignment shop. We believe that luxury should be accessible to all, which is why we offer premium-quality items at affordable prices. Whether you're hunting for a statement furniture piece, a designer outfit, or exquisite home décor, we've got you covered. Elevate your shopping experience with us and discover the joy of finding exceptional items that resonate with your taste. Experience luxury for less at our Chambersburg consignment shop today!

Start Consigning

YOU WON'T FIND STALE OPTIONS

We Keep Our Inventory Refreshed

What sets our Chambersburg consignment shop apart is our commitment to providing a dynamic shopping experience. Our inventory is not static; it's a living, breathing entity that evolves with each passing day. We pride ourselves on curating a selection that surprises and delights our customers. From vintage classics to contemporary marvels, there's always something new to discover. With every visit, you'll encounter fresh additions that spark inspiration and ignite your imagination. Explore our constantly refreshed inventory and find something extraordinary today!

Contact Us
Our Payment Options:

We accept all major credit and debit cards, as well as cash, for your convenience. Shop with confidence knowing that your preferred payment method is accepted at Why Buy New.

A Community of Style Enthusiasts

Join Our Thriving Consignor Network

At our Chambersburg consignment shop, community is at the heart of everything we do. We cherish our relationships with over 6,000 active consignors who contribute to the rich tapestry of our collection. Our consignor network is a vibrant community of style enthusiasts, each bringing their own unique flair to our shelves. By consigning with us, you not only declutter your space but also become part of a collaborative journey towards sustainable and stylish living. Join our thriving consignor network and be part of something special today!

Call Now

the process & policies at Why Buy New

Get Cash for Gently Pre-Loved Items

At Why Buy New, we offer a straightforward and transparent consignment policy to help you turn your pre-loved items into cash. Our process is designed to be hassle-free and beneficial for both sellers and buyers. Click below to see our consignment policy.

Browse Our Online Storefront
Active Wear
Boyd’s Bears
Store Pic 6
Store Pic 7
Store Pic 8
Store Pic 9
Store Pic 10
Evening Wear
Fabric Dooney & Bourke Purse with zip closure & extra strap included
Fine Jewelry 1
Fine Jewelry 2
Fine Jewelry 3
FORMALS-PROM & BRIDAL..NEW & GENTLY USED
Fur Coat
Glitz & Glamour
Handicap Equip
Harley Davidson
Lingerie
Luggage
Mattresses
Men’s Formal Wear
Men’s Wear 1
Consignment Shop
MINI “CAT” BULLDOZER-NIB $18.95
perfumes
Ring 2
toys
Consignment Shop
Scrubs
Vera Bradley Purses etc.
Vintage Clothes & Accessories
Vintage Statue
Vintage Toys
Wigs and Purses
View more

Get fast, local delivery at a competitive rate.

Enjoy the convenience of having your purchases delivered right to your doorstep with our local delivery service. For a nominal fee, we ensure that your items reach you safely and efficiently, saving you time and effort.

The Evolution of Why Buy New

From Humble Beginnings
to Remarkable Growth

When Faye and her husband started Why Buy New, they had no idea it would grow to be what it is today. Since 1996, we've expanded from a little 500 sq. ft. boutique to the 15,000 sq. ft. we have today.

Vintage Clothes & Costumes
A bunch of halloween costumes are hanging on a rack in a store.
Handicap Equipment
Two black wheelchairs are sitting next to each other on a tiled floor.
Harley Davidson Attire
A store filled with lots of clothes and boots.

See Our Quality Used Electronics

Get in Touch
Find Quality Clothing for Everyone in Your Family

Find a wide variety of gently pre-loved, high-quality clothing for everyone! From clothes for kids to formal wear, vintage costumes, scrubs, and beyond, we have your every function and style need met under one roof, all offered at competitive prices.

Contact Us
Shop Our Selection of Stunning Jewelry & Accessories

Find bedazzling necklaces, rings, watches, and more when you shop with us. Look your best and shine bright wherever you go when you select a piece from our range of authentic and stunning collections for both men and women.

Contact Us

Get in Touch with Us Today!

Have a question? We are here to help. Send us a message and we’ll be in touch. 

Contact Us

I have shopped there several times and I love the place. The people are friendly and even help take your stuff out to your vehicle. I really enjoy walking around and looking at everything. But there is so much, you never see it all!  Go and look and shop; tell them Debbie sent you!! You won’t regret it. I promise!!

- Deborah Diehl

Frequently Asked Questions

Have more questions? We're here to help. Call us at 717-504-8089 for assistance.

  • What makes Why Buy New Consignment Shop so popular?

    The success of Why Buy New Consignment Shop stems from our commitment to offering a unique consignment shopping experience. As a consignment shop, we prioritize curating a diverse range of high-quality items that resonate with our customers' tastes. Our consignment shop stands out for its ever-evolving inventory, constantly refreshed to provide something new and exciting for shoppers. Through our dedicated efforts as a consignment shop, we've cultivated a loyal customer base that appreciates the thrill of discovering hidden treasures within our store.


    Over the years, our consignment shop has earned a reputation for being a go-to destination for those seeking affordable yet stylish furniture, clothing, and decor. Our focus on sustainability through consignment has also contributed to our popularity among eco-conscious consumers. As a consignment shop, we take pride in offering a platform for individuals to buy and sell pre-loved items, fostering a sense of community and environmental responsibility. It's this unique blend of curated selections, sustainability, and community engagement that has made Why Buy New Consignment Shop a beloved choice for shoppers seeking quality and value.

  • What is the best way to contact you?

    The best way to contact us at Why Buy New is through our email. You can reach out to us at whybuynew@earthlink.net for any inquiries, questions, or feedback you may have.  You can also call us at 717-504-8089. We look forward to hearing from you and assisting you with your shopping needs!

  • How does consigning with Why Buy New benefit sellers?

    Consigning with Why Buy New provides sellers with a hassle-free way to declutter their homes while earning money from their pre-loved items. Our consignment shop offers a wide reach and exposure through our physical store and online platform, attracting potential buyers locally and beyond. We work with sellers to determine competitive pricing and provide fair commissions on successful sales. With our efficient consignment process and convenient payouts, sellers can turn their unused items into cash and contribute to sustainable shopping practices at the same time.

Consignment Shop

Share by: